KitchenAid Classic mixer.
There’s actually quite a bit that separates these two mixers. I can let you know right now that the KitchenAid Artisan is a much more feature rich mixer. So this comparison isn’t really apples to apples. It’s more like Chevys’ to Cadillacs. The KitchenAid Artisan is an upgrade; each feature is either the same or better. But, are those extras worth the additional cost; I’ll help you decide.
Your KitchenAid mixer is going to take up a fair bit of countertop real estate. There’s just no way around it. The KitchenAid k45ss measures 14 x 8.8 x 14 inches and weighs 22 pounds. The Artisan is a little bigger at 16.4 x 16.3 x 11.2 inches, but not by much.
Power and Performance…
The KitchenAid K45ss comes with a powerful 275-watt motor. That’s significantly lower than the 325-watt motor of the Artisan. More power means better performance. It means you’ll finish some mixing jobs faster with the Artisan. Depending on how often and what you use your mixer for, you might not need the most powerful motor. Heavy users, who anticipate making dozens of bagels a week or something, might need even more power; like the 575-watt KitchenAid Professional.
Both machines have 59-point planetary mixing action. That means both machines have 59 touchpoints per rotation. Your ingredients will be mixed very thoroughly with either machine. Both machines work with the available attachments.
Click here to see more details on the KitchenAid Classic mixer
Click here to see more details on the KitchenAid Artisan mixer
I am willing to pay a little more for convenience. The KitchenAid Artisan has 2 very convenient features; pouring shield, and mixing bowl handle. It might not sound like much, but those two accessories could come in handy if you bake a lot or want to avoid a mess. I drip stuff all the time when pouring from one bowl to another, so this is definitely a bonus.
Also, the head locks in the up or down position which will make it more convenient when you add ingredients to the mixing bowl.
The Cost of Beauty…
The KitchenAid mixer is iconic. The Artisan series is available in 40 different colors, and some of those colors are wild, like watermelon and French blue. While the classic is available in just two pedestrian colors; white and onyx (black).
KitchenAid Artisan mixer.
At first the difference in capacity seems minor; 4.5 versus 5 quarts. To put it another way, you can make 9 dozens of cookies in one batch using the 5-quart Artisan compared to just 6.75 for the classic. This can be significant, again, depending on your usage. If you are a baker, or make tons of mashed potatoes at once, then you might be better off getting the Artisan over the Classic (k45ss).
There’s another aesthetic issue. Not only is the bowl of the Artisan bigger, but it’s also shinier. The Artisan comes with polished stainless steel bowl compared to brushed steel for the classic. Some may prefer the low-key brushed steel look.
The biggest difference is the addition of the work bowl handle on the Artisan model. This simple feature provides added stability when pouring.
Click here to see price on the KitchenAid Classic mixer
Click here to see price on the KitchenAid Artisan mixer